Archives de la liste Chant Octobre 2004

Pour ceux qui lisent l'anglais, une liste de toutes les études qui ont
été fait sur l'homéopathie depuis 1900 sur le site,
http://www.homeowatch.org/research/overview.html :

In 1990, an article in Review of Epidemiology analyzed 40 randomized
trials that had compared homeopathic treatment with standard treatment,
a placebo, or no treatment. The authors concluded that all but three of
the trials had major flaws in their design and that only one of those
three had reported a positive result. The authors concluded that there
is no evidence that homeopathic treatment has any more value than a
placebo.

In 1995, Prescrire International, a French journal that evaluates
pharmaceutical products, published a literature review that concluded:
"As homeopathic treatments are generally used in conditions with
variable outcome or showing spontaneous recovery (hence their
placebo-responsiveness), these treatments are widely considered to have
an effect in some patients. However, despite the large number of
comparative trials carried out to date there is no evidence that
homeopathy is any more effective than placebo therapy given in identical
conditions."

In 1996, a lengthy report was published by the Homoeopathic Medicine
Research Group (HMRG), an expert panel convened by the Commission of the
European Communities. The HMRG included homeopathic
physician-researchers and experts in clinical research, clinical
pharmacology, biostatistics, and clinical epidemiology. Its aim was to
evaluate published and unpublished reports of controlled trials of
homeopathic treatment. After examining 184 reports, the panelists
concluded: (a) only 17 were designed and reported well enough to be
worth considering; (b) in some of these trials, homeopathic approaches
may have exerted a greater effect than a placebo or no treatment; and
(c) the number of participants in these 17 trials was too small to draw
any conclusions about the effectiveness of homeopathic treatment for any
specific conditions.

In 1997, the British journal Lancet published a meta-analysis that
concluded: "We found insufficient evidence . . . that homeopathy is
clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition."

The overall state of homeopathic research is easy to describe: Most is
worthless, and no homeopathic product has been proven effective for any
therapeutic purpose.

In 1999, The Medical Letter on Drugs and Therapeutics, which is the
medical profession's most trusted drug advisory newsletter, summed up
what health professionals should be should be telling patients: "The
chemical content of homeopathic products is often undefined, and some
are so diluted that they are unlikely to contain any of the original
material. These products have not been proven effective for any clinical
condition. There is no good reason to use them."

Désolé, je ne peux pas les traduire tous.

-Peter Jones
Ténor en plein apprentissage à Paris



-----Original Message-----
From: dyg6@xxxxfr [mailto:dyg6@xxxxfr] 
Sent: Sunday, October 03, 2004 11:05 AM
To: liste chant
Subject: re: homéopathie ?

Bonjour l'Homéopathie !

Quand vous discutez avec de grands chanteurs, en activité, de la santé
de la
voix, vous vous apercevez que chacun a son truc. Beaucoup utilisent
l'homéopathie, placebo ou pas. Ce qui en ressort surtout c'est que
l'homéo
sert surtout en prévention et pour les petits bobos. Il est sans doute
délicat de soigner un oedème un peu important par de l'homéo.

Pour ma part j'utilise une série homéo en prévention, après de
nombreuses
"expérimentations" et celà fonctionne bien depuis des années. Mais nous
ne
serons jamais à l'abri d'une quelconque affection, à moins de ne pas
sortir
de chez soi.

Un mot sur les sites: sur le Net vous trouvez , pour n'importe quel
sujet,
le site "pour" et le site "contre", avec chacun des arguments forts .
Difficile de s'y reconnaître si l'on est pas spécialiste. Le Net, en
lui-même , ne donne aucune garantie de vérité ou d'authenticité. Chacun
y
trouvera son compte.

En ce qui concerne l'homéo, pour les petits bobos, essayez et vous
verrez,
chacun voit midi à sa porte !

Bonne journée et bon chant.

Dominique Basile


------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
Informations, archives et désabonnement :
https://chanteur.net/liste-chant